Butterfinger Vs 5Th Avenue: Battle of the two famous chocolates

The Butterfinger and 5th Avenue are two of the most popular candy bars in the United States. Butterfinger is made by Ferrero SpA while 5th Avenue is made by The Hershey Company. Both candies are available in most convenience stores. They are similar in size and shape, but there are some key differences between them.

The most obvious difference is the flavor; 5th Avenue is a chocolate-covered peanut butter bar while Butterfinger is a chocolate-covered caramel-flavored bar. Another difference is the price; 5th Avenue is typically more expensive than Butterfinger. Finally, there is the nutritional value; 5th Avenue has more calories, fat, and sugar than Butterfinger.

Butterfinger Vs 5Th Avenue
Credit: www.youtube.com

What is the Difference between Butterfinger And 5Th Avenue?

There are a few key differences between Butterfinger and 5th Avenue candy bars. For one, Butterfinger is made with peanut butter while 5th Avenue does not contain any peanut products. This makes Butterfinger a good choice for those with peanut allergies.

Another difference is that 5th Avenue candy bars are covered in chocolate, while Butterfingers have a chocolate coating over a peanut butter center. The final major difference is in the size of the two candy bars – 5th Avenue candy bars are significantly larger than Butterfingers.

Packaging & Appearance

There is some difference in their packaging. 5th Avenue candy uses dark Chocolate color packaging while Butterfinger uses Yellow color packaging. The size of the packaging is almost the same but one of the key differences is their packaging color.

Now, If you come to the candy bar appearance, in that case, both 5th Avenue and Butterfinger both have the same texture and appearance. But the 5th Avenue candy bar is a little bit thicker than the Butterfinger.

There is a difference in their coating too. Butterfinger’s coating is made with compound chocolate while 5th Avenue’s coating is made with real chocolate.


Both Butterfinger and 5th Avenue use the same ingredients. But there are some quality differences between these two. Butterfinger uses regular peanuts while 5th Avenue uses ground-roasted peanuts. So in that case I can say 5th Avenue is using better peanuts than Butterfinger.

Another thing is the coating. Butterfinger uses compound chocolate which is not real chocolate as its coating on the other hand 5th Avenue uses real milk chocolate on its coating. So I can feel the taste of real chocolate milk coating while taking 5th Avenue.

Nutrition Facts 

I checked their nutrition value from USDA. From their data, I got some idea about their nutritional value. Butterfinger contains 459 cal while 5th Avenue contains 482 cal per 100g serving. So in the case of calories, 5th Avenue has a little high calories than Butterfinger.

Butterfinger doesn’t contain any cholesterol while 5th Avenue has 6mg of cholesterol which is not good for us. Also, Butterfinger contains 5g of Protein while 5th Avenue contains 9g of Protein.

What to choose between Butterfinger and 5th Avenue?

I have tasted both chocolate so as to do a compare and contrast of Butterfinger and 5th Avenue candy bars. Here are my thoughts: When it comes to taste.

Butterfinger has a richer, more complex flavor that really satisfies my sweet tooth. The 5th Avenue is good too, but it’s just not as flavorful in my opinion. As far as texture goes, I definitely prefer 5th Avenue.

5th Avenue is nice and crunchy, while the Butterfinger is a bit too soft for my liking. When it comes to price, they are both fairly affordable – although Butterfinger is definitely the cheaper option of the two.

My thoughts on Butterfinger vs 5th Avenue candy bars. Personally, I would go for the Butterfinger if you’re looking for flavor and the 5th Avenue if you’re looking for value.

Is 5Th Avenue Candy Bar Discontinued?

No, 5th Avenue candy bars have not been discontinued. They are still being produced by The Hershey Company and are widely available in the United States. There has been some confusion on this topic because Hershey’s did briefly discontinue the production of 5th Avenue candy bars in Canada in 2013.

However, they resumed production a few months later and the candy bar is now once again available in Canada.

What Candy Bar is Most Like Butterfinger?

When it comes to finding a candy bar that tastes like Butterfinger, there are a few options out there. One option is the Baby Ruth candy bar. Baby Ruth has a similar flavor profile to Butterfinger, with a creamy and rich taste.

Another option is the Crunch Bar from Nestle. This bar also has a similar flavor to Butterfinger, with a crunchy texture and a sweet taste. Finally, the Snickers candy bar from Mars also has a similar taste to Butterfinger, with a creamy and nutty flavor.

What Does a 5Th Avenue Bar Taste Like?

The 5th Avenue candy bar was first introduced in 1936 by the Peter Paul Cadbury Company. It is a chocolate and peanut butter-flavored candy bar that is coated in milk chocolate.

The center of the 5th Avenue candy bar is filled with a creamy peanut butter filling. The flavor of the 5th Avenue candy bar is fairly rich and sweet. The milk chocolate coating gives it a smooth and creamy texture, while the peanut butter filling provides a nice contrast in both flavor and texture.

Overall, the 5th Avenue candy bar is a tasty treat that is perfect for those with a sweet tooth!

Butterfinger vs. Fifth Avenue (4/27/21)


When it comes to classic candy bars, there are two that stand out above the rest: Butterfinger and 5th Avenue. Both are delicious, but which one is better? It’s hard to go wrong with either of these two candy bars.

They both have a crispy cookie layer, a creamy peanut butter layer, and a chocolate coating. However, there are some key differences between the two. For starters, Butterfinger has more of a crunch to it thanks to the added cornflakes in the recipe.

The 5th Avenue bar is also chewier because of the molasses that are used in the cookie layer. As for the flavor, some people say that Butterfinger has a stronger peanut butter taste while others find 5th Avenue to be sweeter overall. In the end, it all comes down to personal preference.

Both Butterfinger and 5th Avenue are delicious candy bars that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

1. 5th Avenue Nutritional Data source: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/167985/nutrients 
2. Butterfinger Nutritional Data source: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/167565/nutrients

Leave a Reply